2014 ICE GAP Fund
(The GAP Fund program guidelines have changed for FY 2014. Please read carefully.)
Awards | Proposal Timeline | Project Timeline | Evaluation Criteria | Application Review Committee | PI Eligibility | Eligible Expenses | Budget | Proposal Submission | Proposal Format | DEO Endorsement | Conflict of Interest in Research | Project Reporting | Evergreen Statement| Commercialization Program | IFI Home
Submit Pre-Proposals via email to Paul Dymerski
Pre-Proposals will be accepted through Friday, August 30, 2013
Online Proposal submission thorough UIRIS will open Monday August 19, 2013
1st round proposals will be accepted through Friday, September 20, 2013
The Iowa Centers for Enterprise (ICE), in conjunction with the Office of the Vice President for Research and Economic Development (OVPR&ED), is pleased to announce a seed funding competition designed to expand the commercialization of UI technologies within the state of Iowa. Funds are available to support the development of innovations with commercial potential through a range of stages in technology development, from initial concept, through proof of concept, to licensing and commercialization.
Pre-proposals for unique innovations in a wide range of application areas may be submitted including but not limited to: medical and healthcare, software and services, engineering, and environmental. Existing industry connections are not a prerequisite for funding; however, all projects should have a clear commercial benefit or potential for the state of Iowa, including but not limited to:
- Growth in the Iowa employment base
- Creation of an Iowa company
- Licensing to an existing Iowa company
- Generating revenue for the UI enterprise
Interdisciplinary proposals are encouraged. Applications that do not have a clear connection with commercialization and/or technology development will not be considered responsive to this call for proposals and will not be reviewed.
Funding per project is expected to range from $10,000 to $75,000.
- Pre-proposal Application Closes: Friday, August 30, 2013
- Marketing Analysis: 2-3 weeks (depending on availability of proposer)
- Full Project Proposal Application (by invitation only)
- Awards will be announced individually as committee review is completed
Applicants will be notified if these dates change significantly.
Commercialization Program Enrollment
(New this year)
All GAP project team members are required to enroll in at least one university-sponsored entrepreneurship or commercialization training event during their GAP project. These events will be offered by the UIRF and the JPEC as part of our expanding entrepreneurship program for faculty and staff.
All proposed projects must be designed to be completed in a reasonable amount of time, commensurate with the complexity of the project (one year maximum). A project timeline must be submitted and must include two or more measurable milestones during the timeline. Funding may be tied to meeting specific milestones.
Proposals will be evaluated for their potential to grow and enhance Iowa's economy and generate income with University of Iowa (UI) technology. Each project will be reviewed according to the following criteria (listed in order of importance).
- Commercial Viability: How likely is it that, if the project is successful, there is a viable commercial development path with licensing to an existing, or new Iowa company?
- Technological Viability: Is there is a continuing and viable technological development path?
- Project Viability: How likely is it that the project endpoints can be achieved within projected budget and timeframe?
As proposals are received, a market analysis will be performed to pre-screen for commercial viability. These results will be added to the proposal for the review committee. Proposers are required to participate in this analysis process. Understanding the target market, competition, etc., will aid product development.
Proposals will be reviewed by an Application Review Committee that is comprised of faculty and staff involved in economic development and commercialization activities at UI as well as representatives of the external community experienced in evaluating new technology. The committee’s recommendations will be submitted to the Vice President for Research and Economic Development, who will make the final determination of awards.
All tenure-track or tenured faculty, clinical faculty, research track faculty, research scientists, research engineers, associates, and other staff members who have at least a 50% university appointment during the year of the project are eligible to apply. These individuals are designated as PI-eligible applicants. The proposal may have as many co-PIs as appropriate.
Visiting faculty, lecturers, postdoctoral associates, fellowship trainees, medical residents, graduate students, and undergraduate students should confirm eligibility with the UIRF office prior to submission.
The proposal can be one that was previously submitted to other programs but must satisfy the requirements and objectives listed above.
Eligible Expenses: Budget items may include: research assistant salary, post-doctoral associate salary, undergraduate stipends, and graduate student stipends (fringe benefits and graduate student tuition costs must be included in the budget), external consultants and partners, equipment, supplies, animal care costs, payment to subjects, computer services, and any other costs relevant to the project. Travel expenses are eligible only when the travel is required to conduct the project.
Ineligible Expenses: Principal Investigator(s) (PI) salaries and travel to attend conferences or present findings are not eligible. "Bridging" support to maintain research operations for interim periods between grant termination and funding renewal is not allowed. Contact the OVPR&ED for information to specifically request bridging support.
Enter budget items, costs and justification in appropriate areas of the on-line form.
- Salary: Salary and fringe for all eligible personnel on the project (e.g., research staff, graduate students, and undergraduate students). Note: graduate student tuition costs must also be included as a budget expense.
- External Consultants and Partners: May include content experts, both scientific and commercial, as well as any required contract services.
- Equipment: Amount requested for equipment only. Specify each item.
- Supplies: Amount requested for project supplies, such as purchase of CDs, books, animals, animal care per diem costs, glassware, sera, etc. Specify all major categories.
- Related Services: Amount requested for services performed by non-academic units. Examples include costs to utilize the Small Animal Imaging Facility, DNA Facility, Central Microscopy Facility, etc.
- Travel: Amount requested for all travel-related costs (e.g., airfare, lodging, meals, long-term housing, etc.). Specify each trip. Only travel directly related to the conduct of the proposed project will be considered. Travel expenses to attend conferences and to report results are not eligible.
- Other: Amount for costs not covered in other budget categories. If you believe an item does not fall within any of the categories listed, enter it under “other” and justify it in the text box provided.
- You are strongly encouraged to first look at UI and State of Iowa resources for assistance before seeking outside assistance--i.e. for prototyping, consulting, etc.
If you have questions about the eligibility of budget items, contact Paul Dymerski (319-384-3425).
An appropriate budget should be designed to permit the completion of all award-related activities within the submitted timeline. If project costs exceed the amount requested on the budget, then other confirmed sources of funding must be identified and shown on the budget. The departmental executive officer (DEO) must endorse the availability and projected use of any additional funds required. Justification must be included in the on-line form as to why each item of the budget is necessary for the project.
All internal funding proposals must be submitted electronically via the UIRIS web site. This is a secure site. To gain access to it, you must use your HawkID and password. If you are having difficulties creating the required PDF document, contact OVPR&ED at 319-335-2119.
It is essential that applicants write their proposals so that the project is comprehensible to non-specialists. This is a key element of justifying the potential benefits of the project to other parties, including investors. Thus, one should limit the amount of highly discipline specific jargon used. Minimize the number of abbreviations used. Restrict description of overly technical components of your project. Your objective is to assist the reviewer in understanding the goals, merits and feasibility of your project.
The application must contain the following sections in the order indicated, with each section being clearly identified. Proposals are now submitted in 3 steps. (Please submit the Innovation Summary as early as possible to allow time for the Market Analysis).
Submission 1: Innovation Pre-proposal (Summary)
Submit Pre-Proposals via email to Paul Dymerski
Pre-Proposal will be accepted through Friday, August 30, 2013
- Cover Page: Include the project title, the names and contact information of participants, and a project summary of 200 words or less (maximum: 1 page).
- Innovation (maximum: 1 page):
- What is the envisioned end product or service?
- What limitation, problem, or need does it solve?
- What is novel and/or new about the proposed product or service?
- What is its current state of development?
- What is the most directly comparable product or service currently available?
- What differentiates your technology from other solutions?
- Provide a summary of the purpose of the proposed project. (maximum: 1 page)
- Do you see this as IP for licensing to an existing company, or through a new venture?
- If existing company-who?
- If a new venture, what role will you play in that company?
Submission 2: Market Analysis
A market analysis will be performed by the UIRF if a report is not already on file. You are required to participate. The report will be added to the proposal, and is available to you.
Submission 3: Full Project Description, Expenses, and Timeline
Submit Full Project Proposals through the UIRIS web site
1st round proposals will be accepted through Friday, September 20, 2013
Project Description (maximum: 2 pages):
- Clearly and succinctly identify what product (or process) will be achieved, developed, initiated through the gap funding.
- Provide an explanation of the purpose of the proposed project. Provide convincing arguments as to the significance of the proposed project.
- Describe project aims.
- Describe project endpoints of these aims.
- Discuss what level of endpoints, preferably as a quantitative measure, is required for commercial significance. If levels for comparable products are available, please discuss.
- Timeline for the project.
- All projects must be designed to be completed in a reasonable amount of time, commensurate with the complexity of the project (oneyear maximum).
- All projects must include one or more measurable milestone dates (at least quarterly) for project review.
- Projects tasks and milestone dates must be broken out in a Gantt chart
- If there are deliverables other than the aims and endpoints, describe them.
- All projects must be designed to be completed in a reasonable amount of time, commensurate with the complexity of the project (one
- Feasibility of the Project: The aim(s) of the project should be well correlated with the time and funding limitations of the award. Provide a candid assessment of the likelihood of completing the proposed project (maximum: ½-page).
- Describe Potential Pitfalls of the Proposed Project: List possible problems and difficulties that may arise with the methods and approach described in the proposal. List possible ways to circumvent these pitfalls (maximum: ½-page).
- Next Steps: If the project is successful, what are the next steps anticipated in the commercialization process? Will the intellectual property (IP) be ready for licensing? Is there an interest in a new venture (or existing venture) to market the technology? (maximum: ½-page).
- Budget: A budget justification should detail the planned expenditures and the amount and sources of matching funds. It is not necessary to show or include indirect costs (maximum: 1page).
- CV: A 2-page CV or biosketch must be included for PI and all co-investigators or collaborators (PI-eligible personnel).
- Bibliographical references
- Relevant Papers(maximum of 3)
Applicants are encouraged to discuss their proposal with UIRF staff or contact Paul Dymerski (319-384-3425). Proposals missing the required information or not meeting these formatting standards will automatically be delayed.
Milestone Reviews: The purpose of milestone reviews is to allow ICE to assist the research team in meeting their project goals. At each milestone (or at a minimum each quarter), awardees will meet with ICE to discuss the project. A 1-page status report discussing progress on the project goals must be submitted prior to the meeting. Continued funding will be dependent of demonstrated progress at each milestone. This status report should address two questions:
- Are you on track to complete all project work? If not, please comment as appropriate.
- Are there any technical or business issues, resources, or contacts that ICE can assist with?
Final Report and Meeting: A final meeting with each awardee team will be held to discuss results of the project. A written report is required 3 days prior to the meeting date. Format of the report is flexible, but there should be a focus on endpoints and their commercial significance.
Failure to comply with reporting will make the PI ineligible for any future OVPR&ED internal funding programs.
The Commercialization GAP Fund is an investment in the commercialization of university IP, not a grant. UIRF will try to replenish the Fund by retaining 20% of any future licensing fees received from successful commercialization of the awarded project’s IP, up to a maximum of 3 times the award. This will have no effect on actual licensing fees, but will spread out (and may reduce) future license fees or royalty payments received by the inventors or their university Departments and College.
The applicant’s DEO/Chair will be sent an email message from the Office of the Vice President for Research requesting the endorsement of the proposal shortly after the proposal is submitted. The endorsement must be received electronically from the DEO/Chair by the due date indicated on the email. If the DEO is submitting a proposal, the review will occur at the collegiate level.
At the time you submit a request for these funds, you and the other key personnel on the study team are required to have on file a financial interest disclosure form (submitted through the eCOI system). The Conflict of Interest in Research Office will review the disclosure forms of all key personnel to determine whether there is a conflict of interest, or the appearance of one, related to your proposed research. If it is determined that there is a conflict of interest, then it will need to be managed prior to the awarding of these funds. Information about conflict of interest is available from the Conflict of Interest in Research Office.